How to Store Cookies So You Can Savor Them Longer (Yes, Please!)

2015-06-09
How to Store Cookies So You Can Savor Them Longer (Yes, Please!)

Cookies and bar cookies are among the favorite simple desserts in U.S. kitchens from coast to coast. So much so, in fact, that the average American eats 300 cookies per year! If you'd like a steady supply of homemade cookies but don't have time to bake several times a week, it's time to consider, "How long do cookies last?" so you can maximize their shelf life. With that in mind, we've rounded up our best tips and tricks on how to store cookies. In dough form or baked, bar cookies or drop cookies (you know, the ones you scoop onto cookie sheets), we're covering all you need to know about cookie storage.

How to Store Unbaked Cookie Dough

If you want to get a head start on cooking making, but still want fresh-from-the-oven cookies in a few days, store the dough. Then, when you're ready to serve, remove the dough from storage and bake.

  • Refrigerate Cookie Dough: How long do cookies last in the fridge? Unbaked, you've got about 7 days. Mix cookie dough (except bar cookie batters and meringues) and refrigerate up to 1 week. To store cookie dough, pack dough into airtight containers or shape your slice-and-bake dough into logs and wrap. Store in a tightly-covered container.
  • Freeze Cookie Dough: Most butter- and shortening-based cookie doughs can be frozen for months at a time. Place dough in a tightly-sealed container and freeze using these directions for up to 6 months. Thaw dough in the refrigerator; shape and bake as directed. 

How to Store Baked Cookies at Room Temperature

Curious how long cookies last at room temperature? Most homemade cookies will maintain their taste and texture for up to 3 days. If you leave them out for too long, the cookies begin to harden or dry out. To prevent cookies from becoming stale, cover them with plastic wrap or keep in an airtight container.

  • How to store cookies in a pan: To keep bar cookies in the baking pan, cover the pan with foil or plastic wrap.
  • How to store cookies separately: Store each type of cookie separately in a tightly-covered cookie storage container. Layer delicate unfrosted cookies and cookies with firmly set icing or frosting between sheets of waxed paper in an airtight container. If you mix soft and crisp cookies, the soft cookies will dry out and the crisp cookies will become soft. They may also begin to absorb the flavor of other cookies if combined, so aim to keep each style of cookie recipe in different cookie storage containers.

How to Store Cookies in the Freezer

As we mentioned, most cookie recipes last up to 3 months in freezer bags or containers when you store cookies unfrosted. Get all the freezing information here.

How (and When) to Store Cookies in Multiple Layers or Single Layers

Sturdy cookies and baked goods, such as drop cookies, unfrosted bar cookies, and cookies with firm-set icing can generally be stacked in layers in airtight containers without losing their shape or freshness. So if you're wondering how to store sugar cookies or how to store chocolate chip cookies—two of our holiday season and bake sale MVPs—this efficient way to store cookies is your answer. Layer between sheets of waxed paper in an airtight container or resealable plastic freezer bag. Layer delicate cookies, such as spritz or gingerbread men, between sheets of waxed paper in an airtight container. So how long do cookies last like this? The cookies will stay fresh at room temperature or in the refrigerator up to 3 days, or freeze the cookies up to 3 months. When you're ready to enjoy or share them as a food gift, let the cookies sit at room temperature for 15 minutes, then decorate!

Softer cookies and baked goods, including brownies, cheesecake bars, and any sweets with sticky toppings, are best stored in a single layer in an airtight container. This keeps the treats from losing their shape or smushing together in storage. (Although a mash-up recipe of brownie and cheesecake sounds pretty great to us!) The same timing applies here: Store cookies in a single layer in the refrigerator up to 3 days or freeze up to 3 months.

Now that you're an expert on how to store cookies, the answer to "How long do cookies last?" is more a matter of "How long can you resist them?" rather than "When will they taste less-than-fresh-baked?" Stock that freezer every three months or so and a never-ending supply of homemade cookies can always be yours.

Related Article

How to Make Ultra-Crispy Korean Fried Chicken

How to Make Ultra-Crispy Korean Fried Chicken

This Korean fried chicken recipe is spicy, sweet, and perfectly crispy.
15 Creative, Alternative Lasagna Recipes with Layers of Flavor

15 Creative, Alternative Lasagna Recipes with Layers of Flavor

These traditional and alternative lasagna recipes cover variations on everyone's favorite layered dish. Go for the classic or try something new.
Our Best-Ever Fall Recipes from Better Homes & Gardens

Our Best-Ever Fall Recipes from Better Homes & Gardens

Every year, our Test Kitchen staff and Better Homes and Gardens editors test hundreds of recipes to find the perfect ones for you. We've collected the top-rated favorite fall recipes for you to try, such as hearty casseroles, spiced desserts, savory side dishes, and lush cheesecakes. We suspect these will become part of your treasured recipe collection, too.
18 Healthy Summer Desserts Made with In-Season Fruit

18 Healthy Summer Desserts Made with In-Season Fruit

These light and healthy summer desserts (under 300 calories per serving) are the perfect fruit-filled finish to warm-weather dinners.
Can You Eat Strawberry Leaves? You Bet—Here’s How, and Why You Should

Can You Eat Strawberry Leaves? You Bet—Here’s How, and Why You Should

Can you eat strawberry leaves? Absolutely, and by doing so, you’ll generate less food waste and score some nutrition benefits. Learn why you should eat strawberry leaves, how to clean them, and snag the best strawberry leaf recipes whether you want to sneak them in or let them shine.
Our Test Kitchen's Top Substitutes for Chocolate of Every Type

Our Test Kitchen's Top Substitutes for Chocolate of Every Type

Discover the best substitutes for semisweet, baking, and unsweetened chocolate in your favorite recipes with our Test Kitchen-approved alternatives.
Easy Lemon Chicken Recipes to Perk Up Your Dinner Routine

Easy Lemon Chicken Recipes to Perk Up Your Dinner Routine

Add some zest to your meal plan with these easy lemon chicken recipes. Ranging from family-friendly sheet-pan lemon chicken breast recipes to air-fryer roast chicken that’s perfect for dinner party menus, these easy lemon chicken recipes are definitely worthy of a spot on your regular rotation.
This Smothered Chicken Recipe Is So Good, I Make It Once a Week

This Smothered Chicken Recipe Is So Good, I Make It Once a Week

This one-pan meal is made with chicken thighs that are smothered with a rich, creamy sauce. Here's how to make smothered chicken, including the secret to the most delicious pan gravy.
Roasted Vegetables with Sorghum

Roasted Vegetables with Sorghum

This roasted vegetable and sorghum recipe is the perfect combination of a salad and a side dish. Toss together sorghum and smoky paprika roasted beets, red onion, and fennel as well as arugula and green beans. Finish it with a zesty lemon-honey dressing and enjoy.
Oven Baked Pancakes

Oven Baked Pancakes

Instead of fussing over a skillet, try this easy oven baked pancake recipe that cooks the fluffy breakfast food in a sheet pan.
How to Make Ham and Cheese Quiche In the Slow Cooker

How to Make Ham and Cheese Quiche In the Slow Cooker

Ham and cheese quiche is good, but ham and cheese quiche from your slow cooker is an ideal winter meal. Fill homemade pastry with cheese, ham, eggs, and peppers, and let your slow cooker take care of the rest.
Zoe's Creme Fraiche Pancakes

Zoe's Creme Fraiche Pancakes

Add richness to fluffy pancakes with a touch of creme fraiche and sour cream.
Hasselback Squash

Hasselback Squash

Make butternut squash even more delicious by stuffing it with goat cheese or caramelized onions.
Pulled Pork Sliders Recipe

Pulled Pork Sliders Recipe

Prep these sweet and tangy slow cooker pulled pork sliders when you're serving a crowd—or plan to feed a family through a day of tailgating or potluck dining.
Beef and Cabbage Wraps

Beef and Cabbage Wraps

Set out the tortillas, filling, and condiments and let everyone begin wrapping and rolling. This easy meal is ready in 20 minutes.
10 Gluten-Free Family Meals That Taste Great!

10 Gluten-Free Family Meals That Taste Great!

Gluten-free family meals don't have to be boring. Try our recipes for delicious dinners that are full of flavor but sans gluten.
How to Make Vegetarian Biscuits and Gravy

How to Make Vegetarian Biscuits and Gravy

You can make delicious vegetarian biscuits and gravy and enjoy an old-school dish with updated ingredients.
Vegetable Lasagna with Labneh

Vegetable Lasagna with Labneh

Labneh, a spreadable cheese made from strained yogurt, stands in for ricotta in this skillet lasagna. If you can't find labneh at your grocery store, use whipped cream cheese.
Parrillada Recipe

Parrillada Recipe

Parrillada is a meal that consists of a variety of meats that are grilled or barbecued.
5 Steps for Successfully Grilling Salmon on a Cedar Plank

5 Steps for Successfully Grilling Salmon on a Cedar Plank

Learn about grilling salmon on a cedar plank for a smoky flavor without additional ingredients.